Has the Theory of Reference Rested on a Mistake?
Mark Hinchliff Work on reference and modality by Saul Kripke, David
Kaplan, and others has taught us to distinguish the theory of content from
the theory of reference determination. Because time is like modality,
the lessons we've learned about the contents of names in modal contexts
carry over to names in temporal contexts. However, reflection on some
of the ways in which time differs from modality should lead us to reconsider
not only the descriptive and causal theories (or pictures) of reference
determination but also the philosophical problem of reference determination
itself. Perhaps the theory of reference has rested on a mistake.
|