AND 

    

  Yellowstone National Park

Bighorn Canyon Natl Recreation Area

Grand Teton National Park

Round 2 Survey

Vital Signs Monitoring in
Yellowstone, Bighorn Canyon & 
Grand Teton National Parks

____________________________________________________________________________________
       A Survey of Scientists & Resource Professionals

No longer in service

 

Thank you for taking time to complete this survey for the Vital Signs Monitoring project.  It is shorter than Round 1 and should only take you only about 15 minutes to complete.

If you are not familiar with this project you can read additional background information about our process and review the definitions of key terms that you will encounter in the survey by clicking here.

What does this survey entail? 

Overall, the project involves three rounds of questions that progress from very general to more specific. In the first round (Round 1), we asked resource experts to identify what they consider to be the most important resource components, conditions, or processes that should be monitored. The results have been used to compile a comprehensive list. Now in this survey, Round 2, we ask you to rank order these based upon what you think are the best things to monitor. In the final round, those indicators emerging as the top priorities within each resource area will be systematically evaluated according to criteria of what constitutes a good indicator for the Vital Signs Monitoring program.

  Vital Signs Monitoring: The goal of “Vital Signs” monitoring is to be able to assess the basic health or integrity of park ecosystems and to be able to formulate management actions whenever necessary to maintain the integrity of those ecosystems.

You can be assured of complete confidentiality. The data you submit will be summarized and your name will not be associated with any of your answers.

 


Please enter your name:

 

What is your title or position?
 
Please enter the Email address at which you prefer to be contacted:

For what agency, institution, or organization do you work?

Please enter your Zip code:
 
Do you have familiarity with natural resources or ecosystems found in any of these three parks: (Check all that apply)

  Yellowstone         Grand Teton          Bighorn Canyon 
 

   

_________________________________________________________________

For each of the resource areas listed below, what are the five best things monitor to assess the condition and trend of ecosystems in these national parks? Please answer for those resource areas in which you have expertise. 


  PHYSICAL RESOURCES
  
  AQUATIC  RESOURCES

  VEGETATION
   
  VERTEBRATE SPECIES

  INVERTEBRATE SPECIES
   
  OTHER RESOURCE  COMPONENTS  
OR ECOSYSTEM PROCESSES
 


(Please identify those things that you think should be monitored, regardless of cost.)

 

1.  
  
PHYSICAL RESOURCES (including air, soil, geology)
 

 

 

 

Based upon your knowledge and expertise, please select the five best physical indicator topics to monitor the vital signs of these parks. 

Please check no more than 5 indicator topics below by clicking to mark or unmark 5 boxes.  (If you feel you do not have adequate expertise to choose physical indicator topics, please check the last box then go to the next category, aquatic indicator topics.)

 

Choose only 5:      
    
(To see the reasons people gave for nominating each of these indicator topics, click here.)   
   Climate-related
  
   Air    Soil
  Glaciers
  Air quality/pollution   Soil Structure
Weather history

 

Vehicular emissions   Soil chemistry & nutrition
  Precipitation   Smoke

 

Soil Moisture
  Permafrost    Ozone   Soil erosion
         Dust storms   Wind erosion
   Other  

 

Acid deposition   Slope stability (landslides)
  Noise    Geological   Recreation effects (on nutrient cycling & water)
  Caves   Volcanic activity (seismic)   Fire effects on soils

Fossils   Geological resources (including thermal)    Mining effects
       Geological resources (not thermal)   Cryptogamic crusts
  
  
I do not have enough expertise to select physical indicator topics.
  
   


The goal of vital signs monitoring is to select indicators that could be applied to all of the parks in a network.  If any of the 5 items you checked above apply specifically to one park (Bighorn Canyon, Yellowstone, or Grand Teton), please tell us in the space below.


Go to:

Physical
Aquatic
Vegetation

Vertebrate
Invertebrate
Other
   

  

2.  
  
AQUATIC  RESOURCES (including water quality)
    

Based upon your knowledge and expertise, please select the five best aquatic indicator topics to monitor the vital signs of these parks. 

Please check no more than 5 indicator topics below by clicking to mark or unmark 5 boxes.  (If you feel you do not have adequate expertise to choose aquatic indicator topics, please check the last box then go to the next category, vegetation indicator topics.)

 

Choose only 5:
    
(To see the reasons people gave for nominating each of these indicator topics, click here.)   
   
Aquatic Organisms
  
   Streams    General
 
Aquatic community composition   Stream channel morphology   Water quality/chemistry (general)
 
Exotic species   Stream flow   Direct human inputs (recreation, land use, sewage, etc.)
  Coliforms

 

Small streams   Turbidity & sediment
 
Bacterial mats (geothermal)           Eutrophication 
 
Pathogenic amoebae            Surface water area & lake levels
                         Ground water (level, quantity, quality, chemistry)
                     Radioactive elements
                   Hyporheic zones in thermal areas
                     Bathymetric surveys
   pH 
                    Nutrient transport 
     

   

I do not have enough expertise to select aquatic indicator topics.

The goal of vital signs monitoring is to select indicators that could be applied to all of the parks in a network.  If any of the 5 items you checked above apply specifically to one park (Bighorn Canyon, Yellowstone, or Grand Teton), please tell us in the space below. 


   

Go to:

Physical
Aquatic
Vegetation

Vertebrate
Invertebrate
Other
   

 


3.

VEGETATION RESOURCES
  
  

 

Based upon your knowledge and expertise, please select the five best vegetation indicator topics to monitor the vital signs of these parks. 

Please check no more than 5 indicator topics below by clicking to mark or unmark 5 boxes.  (If you feel you do not have adequate expertise to choose vegetation indicator topics, please check the last box then go to the next category, vertebrate indicator topics.)

Choose only 5:
    
(To see the reasons people gave for nominating each of these indicator topics, click here.)   
  Individual Species 
    

Communities 
  
Landscape elements 
 
Aspen   Community structure   Proportion of landscape in different veg types 
 
Lichen   Riparian communities & wetlands   Landscape fragmentation
 
Whitebark pine / Limber pine /Lodgepole pine   Communities on thermal streams   Fuel loadings
 
Sagebrush   Species diversity   Fire history    
 
Threatened & Endangered Spp   Successional status  
Processes/functions
 
Willow   Range condition   Resilience
 
Native grasses & forbs           Primary productivity (also forage production)
 
Aristida purpurea   Specific communities   Soil-plant relationships (also nutrient cycling)
 
Sullivantia hopemanii  
Juniper woodlands   Effects of fire exclusion
 
Arbonia ammophila
Douglas fir woodlands   Grazing effects
  
Specific exotic species
  
  Cushion plant communities   
Other
 
Bromus tectorum (cheat grass)   Alpine communities   Plant genetics
 
Tamarix chinensis (saltcedar)   Location of treelines or ecotones
 
Centauries repens             Vegetation chemistry
   General
Exotic and noxious plant species
Standing dead trees
  
 
   
                 Human Development 
   I do not have enough expertise to select vegetative indicator topics.        
  
The goal of vital signs monitoring is to select indicators that could be applied to all of the parks in a network.  If any of the 5 items you checked above apply specifically to one park (Bighorn Canyon, Yellowstone, or Grand Teton), please tell us in the space below.


Go to:

Physical
Aquatic
Vegetation

Vertebrate
Invertebrate
Other
   

 


4.

VERTEBRATE
SPECIES 
             
  

 

Based upon your knowledge and expertise, please select the five best vertebrate species indicator topics to monitor the vital signs of these parks. 

Please check no more than 5 indicator topics below by clicking to mark or unmark 5 boxes.  (If you feel you do not have adequate expertise to choose vertebrate species indicator topics, please check the last box then go to the next category, invertebrate species indicator topics.)

 
Choose only 5:
  
(To see the reasons people gave for nominating each of these indicator topics, click here.)   
  

Ungulates Non-ungulate Mammals Fish
 
Elk   Forest carnivores (fisher, marten, lynx, wolf, wolverine)   Cutthroat trout
 
Moose    Small mammals   Non-native fish species

   

 
Pronghorn antelope

  

 

Bears   General fish communities 

 

              
Other Vertebrate
   
 
Bison   Migratory bird species   Species diversity
 
Bighorn sheep   Non-migratory bird species (non-waterfowl)   Threatened & endangered species
 
  Waterfowl (swans)   Keystone species
      
Raptors  
Population dynamics (density, use patterns)
   
  
Herps
  Bats   Predator/Prey relationships
 
Amphibians        Disease

Reptiles          Biogeochemistry  
     
   I do not have enough expertise to select vertebrate species indicator topics. 
  

The goal of vital signs monitoring is to select indicators that could be applied to all of the parks in a network.  If any of the 5 items you checked above apply specifically to one park (Bighorn Canyon, Yellowstone, or Grand Teton), please tell us in the space below.


   

Go to:

Physical
Aquatic
Vegetation

Vertebrate
Invertebrate
Other 

 


5.

INVERTEBRATE
SPECIES
          
  

 

Based upon your knowledge and expertise, please select the five best invertebrate species indicator topics to monitor the vital signs of these parks. 

Please check no more than 5 indicator topics below by clicking to mark or unmark 5 boxes.  (If you feel you do not have adequate expertise to choose invertebrate species indicator topics, please check the last box then go to the next question.)

 
Choose only 5:
   
(To see the reasons people gave for nominating each of these indicator topics, click here.)   
   Species
  
    Communities 
  
   Other 
  
 
Macroinvertebrates (aquatic insects & macrobenthic organisms)   Insect diversity (abundance)   Diseases
 
Mosquitoes   Food web complexity      
 
Soil/water microbes   Invertebrate communities      
 
Exotic species      
 
Beetles            
 
Butterflies            
 
Mussels/mollusks             
 
Pollinators            
 
Odonata            
 
I do not have enough expertise to select invertebrate species indicator topics.   

The goal of vital signs monitoring is to select indicators that could be applied to all of the parks in a network.  If any of the 5 items you checked above apply specifically to one park (Bighorn Canyon, Yellowstone, or Grand Teton), please tell us in the space below.



   

Go to:

Physical
Aquatic
Vegetation

Vertebrate
Invertebrate
Other
  

 


6.


OTHER
RESOURCE COMPONENTS OR ECOSYSTEM PROCESSES
   

   

Are there any other resource components or ecosystem processes that you think should be monitored to assess the condition and trend of ecosystems in these national parks? 


Other Resource Components or Ecosystem Processes:


Reason for selection as an important monitoring priority (including existing or potential threats):
 

In which national park(s) should this be monitored?

Yellowstone   Grand Teton
Bighorn Canyon

    

Do you have any other suggestions concerning Vital Signs Monitoring in Bighorn Canyon, Grand Teton or Yellowstone National Parks? (Please enter in the space below:)

 

If you have additional suggestions or inquiries about this questionnaire, please email your comments to troyh@uidaho.edu or edkrumpe@uidaho.edu 

 

 

Thank you for your input.  When you have finished completing this survey, please click on the "submit" button below.

 

                     

  

  

________________________________________________________________________________

Background Information on the Vital Signs Monitoring survey process:

What is Vital Signs Monitoring and how does this survey process fit in? 

This project is part of a larger process to identify and implement monitoring of critical “vital signs” of national park health. This component solicits expert opinion about monitoring needs. Other components include

  • documenting the history of monitoring efforts within each park,

  • incorporation of recommendations from a Science Advisory Committee, and

  • final selection of monitoring models and/or methods.  


Round 1
Round 2
Round 3

A detailed discussion of National Park Service Inventory and Monitoring program, including Vital Signs Monitoring, can be viewed at http://www.nature.nps.gov/im/  or http://www.nature.nps.gov/im/monitor/handbook.htm 

 

How are we using terminology?

Monitoring: Monitoring involves carefully designed programs intended to track and evaluate the condition of specifically designated resources. Natural resource monitoring is conducted to:

  1. Detect significant changes in resource abundance, condition, population structure, or ecological processes;

  2. Develop information on linkages between changes in resource conditions and their causes;

  3. Provide field validation for and modeling efforts associated with monitoring;  and

  4. Evaluate the effects of some management action on population or community dynamics or ecological processes.

Vital Signs are key elements that indicate the health of an ecosystem.  Vital signs may occur at any level of organization including landscape, community, population or genetic levels. They may be compositional (based upon constituent elements of the system), structural (based upon the organization of the system), or functional (based upon ecological processes).

        Vital signs can be any measurable feature of the environment that provides insights into the state of the ecosystem. They are things that:

  • Identify status and trends of ecosystem health

  • Define normal limits of variation

  • Provide early warning of situations that require intervention

  • Suggest remedial treatments and frame research hypotheses

  • Determine compliance with laws and regulations

GO BACK TO TOP