Alli Machlis [teaching assistant/practicum experience]
Engl 345
Study Questions
The Winter's Tale
- In 1.2, how do specific metaphors
(for the female body and the cuckolded man) clarify Leontes' concerns?
- In 1.2, how does Leontes'
banter with Mamillius, rather than reassuring Leontes that Mamillius is
really his son, instead frustrate the King and fuel his confusion?
- In 1.2, Leontes and Polixenes
identify their childhood together as a time when they thought they would
be "boy[s] eternal," a time when they merely traded "innocence
for innocence." How do they explain such a change? Does the explaination
offered by Leontes and Polixenes seem accurate?
- In 1.2, lines 352-364, Camillo
laments his new role of "cupbearer." How does he understand his
new position and why might he make the decision to tell Polixenes about
Leontes' jealousy. How does his advice to Polixenes echo his own understanding
of kingly power? (lines 432-35).
- According to the Norton headnotes,
romances like The Winter's Tale are only resolved by "miraculous reversals."
How does this "romance" blur the lines between tragedy and comedy,
and what is the tragic cost to the social order and characters of the play?
- In the beginning of 2.1,
Mamillius exchanges ideas about women with his mother and her
ladies-in-waiting. How might this conversation evoke larger social
arguments about men and women in Shakespearean culture?
- Upon discovering the departure
of Camillo and Polixenes, Leontes remarks, "How blest am I in my just
censure, in my true opinion!" How do his comments connect his concerns
of female infidelity to those exhibited by other Shakespearean characters
from other plays?
- How might the use of nature
as both a tragic and renewing force "save" Leontes and Hermione
from retelling the story of Othello and Desdemona?
- When accused, Hermione asks
Leontes, "How will this grieve you / When you shall come to clearer
knowledge, that / You thus have published me?" How do Leontes' accusations
later grieve him?
- In 2.1 Antigonus tells Leontes
"you are abused, and by some putter-on / That will be damed for't.
Would I knew the villain," in a passage that echoes Emilia's words
to Othello. What villain plagues Leontes?
- Why might Paulina claim in
2.2 that "the office becomes a woman best," referring to the task
of telling the King that Hermione is innocent and has delivered a baby girl?
How might Paulina possess the power to change Leontes’ mind?
- Paulina’s insistence
on showing Leontes his daughter leads him to call her a "mankind witch."
In what similar ways does Leontes chastise Paulina and Antigonus in 2.3?
- How does Paulina appeal to her
husband to defy Leontes?
- How does Hermione defend herself
against Leontes' claims in the trial scene of 3.2?
- Leontes realizes his wrongdoing
fairly quickly, exclaiming "Apollo's angry, and the heavens themselves
do strike at my injustice," when he sees Hermione suffering after hearing
about the death of her son (3.2 143-4). Why then, might the play lapse sixteen
years before restoring the kingdom to its "natural" order?
- Why does the Old Shepherd
identify the gold next to Perdita as "fairy gold?" How does this
understanding of prophecy distinguish the characther of both the Old Shepherd
and the Bohemia he lives in? How does this opinion of prophecy connect to
the play as a whole?
- How do Polixenes' concerns
about Florizel’s love for Perdita echo the paternal concerns of Leontes
in the first half of the play?
- How does Autolycus' role reflect
a transition from tragedy to comedy in the middle of the play?
- How does Florizel's disguise
as Doricles reflect/exhibit the social corcerns about class status that
permeate the relationships of The Winter's Tale? What class tensions are exposed in the play.
- The Norton headnotes describe
Perdita's life in Bohemia as consciously rustic and primitive. Why might
Shakespeare create such a world?
- In 4.4, the disguised
Polixenes debates ideas about nature and art with Perdita. Based on their
social positions, why might they approach these topics from different
directions?
- How does the play restore or
maintain hierarchical class distinctions in Act 4?
- Why might Polixenes direct
his wrath at the Old Shepherd when he discovers his son's plans to marry
Perdita? How does the Old Shepherd react to Perdita's knowledge that Doricles
is the Prince, and how are these responses connected to the ongoing concerns
of paternal authority in the play?
- What tensions still exist at
the play's close? Sean McEvoy's chapter on "Understanding Romance" is an important aspect of our reading and study, and he addresses a good range of issues about the 'genre' and this play. Here is one of his closing comments: "At the end of The Winter's Tale there is a sense of wasted years . . . . [one feels] that a better world has been glimpsed in these plays [including The Tempest], even if palpably not achieved" (Shakespeare: The Basics, second ed. 255).