Passing Sight Distance
While passing is not an event that is a major factor in the design of
four-lane highways, it is a critical component of two-lane highway design. The
capacity of a two-lane roadway is greatly increased if a large percentage of the roadway's
length can be used for passing. On the other hand, providing a sufficient passing
sight distance over large portions of the roadway can be very expensive.
Simply put, the passing sight distance is the length of roadway that the driver of the
passing vehicle must be able to see initially, in order to make a passing maneuver safely.
Our real goal is to provide most drivers with a sight distance that gives them a
feeling of safety and that encourages them to pass slower vehicles.
Calculating the passing sight distance required for a given roadway is best
accomplished using a simple model. The model that is normally used incorporates three
vehicles, and is based on six assumptions:
1.) The vehicle being passed travels at a constant speed throughout the passing
maneuver.
2.) The passing vehicle follows the slow vehicle into the passing section.
3.) Upon entering the passing section, the passing vehicle requires some time to
perceive that the opposing lane is clear and to begin accelerating.
4.) While in the left lane, the passing vehicle travels at an average speed that is
10 mph faster than the vehicle being passed.
5.) An opposing vehicle is coming toward the passing vehicle.
6.) There is an adequate clearance distance between the passing vehicle and the
opposing vehicle when the passing vehicle returns to the right lane.
Under these assumptions, the passing sight distance can be divided into four
quantifiable portions:
d1 -- The distance the passing vehicle travels while contemplating the passing
maneuver, and while accelerating to the point of encroachment on the left lane.
d2 -- The length of roadway that is traversed by the passing vehicle while it occupies the
left lane.
d3 -- The clearance distance between the passing vehicle and the opposing vehicle when the
passing vehicle returns to the right lane.
d4 -- The distance that the opposing vehicle travels during the final 2/3 of the period
when the passing vehicle is in the left lane.
Because the purpose of these specific distances might not be obvious at this point, a
short discussion of each of these distances can be found below. In addition, figure
1.0 below gives a graphical explanation of these distances.
Figure 1.0: Diagram of Passing Sight Distance Components
Source: AASHTO, 1994
d1
The perception-reaction-acceleration distance isn't hard to understand or to
justify. The only aspect of this distance that might be confusing is the simultaneous
nature of the perception and acceleration. Some drivers will begin accelerating
before they enter the passing section and will continue to accelerate while they scan the
opposing lane for traffic. These drivers tend to accelerate at a reduced
rate. Other drivers will avoid accelerating until they have determined that the
opposing lane is clear, but they will accelerate at a higher rate once they have decided
to pass. The net effect is that the perception-reaction-acceleration distance is
identical for both types of drivers. The distance d1 and the corresponding time t1
were measured for several different passing vehicle speeds. More recent research has
confirmed that the accepted values are conservative. See table 1.0.
d2
The distance traveled during the occupancy of the left lane is also easy to
understand. Since the speed of the passing vehicle was assumed to be 10 mph faster
than the overtaken vehicle, all we need to know to calculate the distance d2 is the time
that the passing vehicle occupies the left lane. Values for this time interval were
measured for several different passing vehicle speeds. These measured values were
then used to develop design values for d2. See table 1.0.
d3
The clearance distance might not seem necessary at first, but for now lets take it
on faith that an opposing vehicle is necessary. If this is the case, a maneuver that
feels safe will require that a certain length of roadway is present between the passing
vehicle and the opposing vehicle when the passing vehicle returns to the relative safety
of the right lane. The clearance distance that drivers require depends on their
personality. A timid driver might require several hundred feet of clearance distance,
while a more aggressive driver might consider exchanging side mirrors a perfectly
acceptable practice. Studies have shown that the clearance distance is normally
between 100 and 300 feet. See table 1.0.
d4
The opposing vehicle encroachment distance is the distance that seems to be the most
troubling for students. Let us picture a passing section that is terminated by a
sharp reduction in grade, which prevents the passing driver from seeing any vehicles
beyond the end of the passing section. Let us also assume that the length of the
passing section is equal to the sum of the distances d1 and d2. Our passing vehicle
driver could pass the slower vehicle before leaving the passing section, but she might be
flirting with destiny in doing so. Her principal problem is that she can't see if
there are any opposing vehicles beyond the passing section that might conflict with her
during the maneuver.
The question now is, how much extra sight distance would she need to feel secure
that an opposing vehicle would not conflict with her while she is in the left
lane? If we assume that she can abort her maneuver if an opposing vehicle appears
during the interval t1 or during the first third of the interval t2, we can reduce the
sight distance that we need to provide.
Lets say that we make the passing section length equal to the passing sight
distance as defined in reality (d = d1 + d2 + d3 + d4). If an opposing vehicle
appears just after the first third of the interval t2 is over, the passing car can still
safely pass the slower car and return to the right lane before the opposing car becomes a
threat. This is because the opposing vehicle is a distance 2/3*d2 +d3 + d4 away from
the passing vehicle. By the time that the passing vehicle has traveled the remaining
2/3*d2 and returned to the right lane, the opposing car will have traveled d4, and the
clearance distance d3 will separate them. This is why we add the distances d3 and d4 to
the passing sight distance. The distance d4 is calculated by multiplying the speed of
the opposing vehicle (normally assumed to be the speed of the passing vehicle) by 2/3*t2.
The table below summarizes the results of field observations directed toward
quantifying the various aspects of the passing sight distance (AASHTO, 1994).
Speed Group (km/h) |
50-65 |
66-80 |
81-95 |
96-110 |
Average Passing Speed
(km/h) |
56.2 |
70.0 |
84.5 |
99.8 |
Initial
Maneuver: |
Average acceleration (km/h/s) |
2.25 |
2.30 |
2.37 |
2.41 |
Time (s) |
3.6 |
4.0 |
4.3 |
4.5 |
Distance Traveled (m) |
45 |
65 |
90 |
110 |
Occupation
of the Left Lane: |
Time (s) |
9.3 |
10.0 |
10.7 |
11.3 |
Distance Traveled (m) |
145 |
195 |
250 |
315 |
Clearance
Length: |
Distance Traveled (m) |
30 |
55 |
75 |
90 |
Opposing
Vehicle: |
Distance Traveled (m) |
95 |
130 |
165 |
210 |
|
Total Distance (m) |
315 |
445 |
580 |
725 |
Now that we know how to calculate
the required passing sight distance, how do we calculate the actual passing sight distance
that we have provided in our geometric design? To do this, we simply assume that the
driver's eyes are at a height of 3.5 ft from the road surface and the opposing vehicle is
4.25 ft tall. The actual passing sight distance is the length of roadway ahead over
which an object 4.25 ft tall would be visible, if your eyes were at an elevation of 3.5
ft.
|